Secret Assets Owners
  • Investing
  • World News
  • Politics
  • Stock
  • Editor’s Pick
Editor's PickInvesting

Libertarian Consistency

by September 3, 2024
September 3, 2024

Jeffrey Miron

Popular opinion views liberalism and conservatism as radically different perspectives about the proper size and scope of government.

Liberals and conservatives do advocate dramatically different policies regarding abortion, drugs, guns, economic regulation, climate change, criminal justice, and more.

Yet liberal and conservative perspectives are the same in one key respect: both advocate using government to impose particular values. Conservatives want to ban drugs, liberals guns. Conservatives advocate banning abortions, liberals subsidizing them. Conservatives support subsidies for home schooling and religious schools, liberals the same for low-income housing and “clean” energy. Liberals advocate reparations for descendants of slaves, while conservatives want to ban affirmative action. Conservatives propose teaching traditional religious values in school, while liberals support critical race theory and LGBTQ+ themes in school curricula. Thus the goals of favored policies differ, but not the belief that government should promote specific views.

Indeed, liberal and conservative preferred policies—all of which involve government interference with private decisions—are often close to indistinguishable; on immigration and trade restrictions, industrial policies, protecting Social Security and Medicare, lowering drug prices, regulation of social media content, and more, conservative and liberal positions differ in details but not overall thrust.

In a few cases, liberals and conservatives agree on smaller government: land use regulation, federal prisons, government surveillance, civil asset forfeiture, eminent domain, and corporate bailouts. But these are exceptions.

Libertarianism differs fundamentally from both the liberal and conservative perspectives. While accepting that private arrangements are imperfect, libertarianism consistently asks whether government intervention does more harm than good. And it applies this skepticism regardless of the associated “values.”

Thus libertarianism argues against both drug prohibition and gun control; against government protection of unions, but not against unions per se; against government-imposed affirmative action, but not against privately adopted affirmative action; against any government-imposed content moderation of social media, but not against private moderation policies; against all trade and immigration restrictions; against government restrictions on school choice; against government-mandated licenses; and against the government defining marriage.

Perhaps libertarians are wrong about the merits of some government interventions. But applying a consistent lens across policies helps understand the inconsistencies of both liberal and conservative perspectives.

This article appeared on Substack on September 1, 2024. Constantin Wells, a former exchange student at Harvard, co-wrote this post.

previous post
Trump’s IVF Plan Is a Mistake
next post
Mongolia ignores ICC demands to arrest Putin during state visit

You may also like

ICE Agents Routinely Mask Up When Seizing People—That’s...

May 12, 2025

Friday Feature: MCP Academy

May 9, 2025

Luna Introduces PATRIOT Act Repeal Bill

May 9, 2025

In Congress, a Move To Strip Courts of...

May 9, 2025

Los Angeles Corruption

May 8, 2025

Medicaid Is Driving Deficits: Republicans Are Scarcely Tapping...

May 13, 2025

Fraud in Federal Programs

May 13, 2025

A Tale of Two Trade Deals

May 12, 2025

Trump Attempts Price Controls on Prescription Drugs

May 12, 2025

No, It’s Not Price Controls: Trump’s Executive Order...

May 12, 2025

ICE Agents Routinely Mask Up When Seizing People—That’s...

May 12, 2025

Friday Feature: MCP Academy

May 9, 2025

Luna Introduces PATRIOT Act Repeal Bill

May 9, 2025

In Congress, a Move To Strip Courts of...

May 9, 2025

Los Angeles Corruption

May 8, 2025

Medicaid Is Driving Deficits: Republicans Are Scarcely Tapping...

May 13, 2025

Fraud in Federal Programs

May 13, 2025

A Tale of Two Trade Deals

May 12, 2025

Trump Attempts Price Controls on Prescription Drugs

May 12, 2025

No, It’s Not Price Controls: Trump’s Executive Order...

May 12, 2025
Join The Exclusive Subscription Today And Get Premium Articles For Free


Your information is secure and your privacy is protected. By opting in you agree to receive emails from us. Remember that you can opt-out any time, we hate spam too!

Recent Posts

  • Trump’s ‘wrong-headed’ effort to lower drug costs amounts to price control: expert

    May 13, 2025
  • Lawsuit tracker: New resistance battling Trump’s second term through onslaught of lawsuits taking aim at EOs

    May 13, 2025
  • Biden made Harris campaign a ‘nightmare,’ destroyed her chances by staying in 2024 race too long, aides charge

    May 13, 2025
  • Gabbard fires ‘deep state’ heads of National Intelligence Council to root out ‘politicization of intel’

    May 13, 2025
  • Trump offers Iran choice: Drop nuclear weapons or face ‘maximum pressure’

    May 13, 2025
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 SecretAssetsOwners.com All Rights Reserved.


Back To Top
Secret Assets Owners
  • Investing
  • World News
  • Politics
  • Stock
  • Editor’s Pick