Secret Assets Owners
  • Investing
  • World News
  • Politics
  • Stock
  • Editor’s Pick
Editor's PickInvesting

Tobacco Harm Reduction Opponents Should “Consider the Conterfactual”

by August 23, 2024
August 23, 2024

Jeffrey A. Singer

A paper published in the journal Harm Reduction in June by Arielle Selya, PhD argues against the “gateway” hypothesis that nicotine-vaping prohibitionists like to employ. Electronic nicotine delivery systems (ENDS) opponents point to studies that suggest teens who use e‑cigarettes may be more likely to use illicit drugs and tobacco. (To be logically consistent, they would also have to claim that tobacco is a gateway to using illicit drugs.) However, as is the case with similar, long-ago debunked arguments against cannabis use as a gateway to harder drugs, the hypothesis is based on observational studies that show correlation, not causation.

Congress commissioned the Institute of Medicine of the National Academy of Sciences to investigate whether cannabis is a gateway drug to other, more harmful illicit substances, and in 1999 it concluded:

Patterns in progression of drug use from adolescence to adulthood are strikingly regular. Because it is the most widely used illicit drug, marijuana is predictably the first illicit drug most people encounter. Not surprisingly, most users of other illicit drugs have used marijuana first. In fact, most drug users begin with alcohol and nicotine before marijuana — usually before they are of legal age.

In the sense that marijuana use typically precedes rather than follows initiation of other illicit drug use, it is indeed a “gateway” drug. But because underage smoking and alcohol use typically precede marijuana use, marijuana is not the most common, and is rarely the first, “gateway” to illicit drug use. There is no conclusive evidence that the drug effects of marijuana are causally linked to the subsequent abuse of other illicit drugs.

An alternative explanation for these correlations is what researchers call “common liability.” The common liability hypothesis claims that users of various substances share a common attraction to a component or effect of those substances. In the case of vaping and tobacco smoking, the component is nicotine.

Dr. Selya writes:

[E]arly conceptualizations of the gateway concept—marijuana use leading to subsequent use of “harder” substances—is no longer accepted as a plausible hypothesis. It has since been dismissed for the same reasons: that the association between marijuana use and other substance use reflects common risk factors rather than a causal relationship…

… rather than ENDS use directly causing some youth to also smoke cigarettes (as in the gateway explanation), youths’ pre-existing tendency to use products containing nicotine explains why youth who use ENDS also smoke cigarettes. This is referred to as the common liability explanation because the same list of individual characteristics mentioned above are common to both ENDS use and cigarette smoking, and having these characteristics is a liability (i.e., they are risk factors) for using any product that contains nicotine.

In an interview with Filter Magazine, Dr. Selya states, “The real question is: What would these youths have done in a hypothetical world without e‑cigarettes? We call this the ‘counterfactual.’”

Youth tobacco smoking has been declining since 2004. “Common liability” may explain why the rate of decline in youth tobacco smoking accelerated after e‑cigarettes appeared on the scene. It may also explain a UK survey released this month showing nearly 3 million people have used nicotine e‑cigarettes to quit smoking since 2019, and a record 5.3 million people currently vape in the UK (11 percent of the population).

Of course, policymakers should not interfere with adults’ right to vape because of concerns that minors might do so. Besides, as is the case with alcohol, it is already illegal for retailers to sell e‑cigarettes to anyone under age 21. However, in their zeal to restrict access to alternative nicotine delivery systems, policymakers should remember to consider the counterfactual.

previous post
State Tax Cuts: Cheers and Jeers
next post
Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. to endorse Trump for president, court filing shows

You may also like

Trump’s New Manufacturing Tax Break Could be a...

May 8, 2025

Affordable Housing Testimony

May 8, 2025

CBO Score Shows Medicaid Is Inefficient and Current...

May 7, 2025

Social Security’s Financial Crisis in Pictures

May 7, 2025

Tariffs and Agriculture: Reaping What You Sow?

May 5, 2025

Friday Feature: MCP Academy

May 9, 2025

Luna Introduces PATRIOT Act Repeal Bill

May 9, 2025

In Congress, a Move To Strip Courts of...

May 9, 2025

Los Angeles Corruption

May 8, 2025

Corporate Welfare and Low-Income Welfare

May 8, 2025

Trump’s New Manufacturing Tax Break Could be a...

May 8, 2025

Affordable Housing Testimony

May 8, 2025

CBO Score Shows Medicaid Is Inefficient and Current...

May 7, 2025

Social Security’s Financial Crisis in Pictures

May 7, 2025

Tariffs and Agriculture: Reaping What You Sow?

May 5, 2025

Friday Feature: MCP Academy

May 9, 2025

Luna Introduces PATRIOT Act Repeal Bill

May 9, 2025

In Congress, a Move To Strip Courts of...

May 9, 2025

Los Angeles Corruption

May 8, 2025

Corporate Welfare and Low-Income Welfare

May 8, 2025
Join The Exclusive Subscription Today And Get Premium Articles For Free


Your information is secure and your privacy is protected. By opting in you agree to receive emails from us. Remember that you can opt-out any time, we hate spam too!

Recent Posts

  • Trump inks trade deal with UK, previews China trade negotiations during 16th week in office

    May 10, 2025
  • Denmark PM says ‘you cannot spy against an ally’ following reports of US spying on Greenland

    May 10, 2025
  • Mexico sues Google for changing ‘Gulf of Mexico’ to ‘Gulf of America’ after Trump’s order

    May 10, 2025
  • Pakistan says it has struck military targets inside India in series of new attacks

    May 10, 2025
  • Massachusetts suspect charged with attempting to assassinate a Cabinet nominee

    May 10, 2025
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 SecretAssetsOwners.com All Rights Reserved.


Back To Top
Secret Assets Owners
  • Investing
  • World News
  • Politics
  • Stock
  • Editor’s Pick